Tag Archives: gay

Social Opinion and the Supreme Court

HRC Marriage Equality Red LogoThe gay marriage equality picture sure changed in the less than two months since the Supreme Court heard testimony about Proposition 8 and DOMA.  I did not expect a wide-ranging ruling that approved gay marriage based on some of Chief Justice Roberts’ questions.  It seemed more likely the Court would strike down DOMA, particularly since the congressional record showed that DOMA was enacted to show Congressional disapproval of gay people.  One of the highlights was when the pro DOMA attorney was surprised to learn that information.

Court observers said that the Supreme Court would be hesitant to issue a broad ruling in favor of gay marriage.  They said the Court felt bruised over taking the Bush vs. Gore case that decided the 2000 election.  Also, they noted the social divide and criticism the Court still takes over Roe vs. Wade.

Against that backdrop, it is interesting to see how quickly the tide has turned in favor of marriage equality.  The Court is not supposed to be swayed by politics or public opinion, per my high school government class.  Theory is not reality, though, and the Court does not operate in a vacuüm.

Before the last two weeks, when Rhode Island, Delaware, and Minnesota each approved gay marriage, the most I thought the Court might do was strike down prohibitions against civil unions.  That compromise would leave lots of people angry, but it would be one way to extend legal rights without being perceived as infringing on churches that oppose gay marriage.  I think a ruling in favor of gay marriage is more likely now, and will be even more probable if Illinois approves gay marriage before the Court issues its opinions.

For my friends who are on the other side of this issue, I emphasize that no church has been forced to perform a gay marriage in any of the states with marriage equality.  I think the people who try to tie commercial cases to religious freedom have a weak argument.  I am all for religious freedom.  I do not think the Mormon church needs to fear gay civil marriage as a threat to temple marriage.  The church has never been forced to perform temple marriages for people who do not follow the Word of Wisdom, even though the prohibited substances are legal products.

Here are two links.  This article about twelve states that will probably legalize gay marriage in the next two years is two months old.  It is interesting to see what has happened since the article was written.  This blog post is from one of my Facebook friends, John G-W, in Minnesota.  He talks about the need for marriage equality proponents and opponents to talk with each other so they can learn to understand each other even if they do not agree.

I did not expect gay marriage to move forward so quickly when I was working with Mormons for Equality last year.  I am happy for my gay Facebook friends in states where their marriages are recognized.  I hope Federal recognition for gay couples in all states comes next month via the Supreme Court.

A Few More “Still Water” Thoughts + Sugar Cookies

(This is a continuation of this post about the Gay Mormon Stories interview with Bryan Hendrickson and Adam Allred.  It ties in with some other thoughts and experiences.)

Adam and Bryan talked about their first reactions to meeting gay people.  They said the people they met were not the evil, horrible people that they had heard about from church and society in general.  Rather, they met kind, intelligent, creative, artistic, sensitive, and talented people.

I had the same experience.  I was talking with a friend after I became involved with the chorus.  She wanted to know about the people who I had met.  I told her they included a banker, some people in education and education administration, small business owners, retail managers, a florist, a pharmacist, and someone in hospital administration.  She replied, “They sound like a good group of people.”  That is what I have found.

Gregory and I had a nice time meeting a few gay Mormons the other week.  Each of the people were kind and friendly. They had a variety of work and education experiences.    I thought they would be a good addition to any group, yet almost everyone had experienced some form of rejection.

Straight people do not need to be afraid of gay people.  We do not have an evil gay agenda nor do we want to destroy the world.  We want to be treated fairly.  We want to be treated kindly.  We want to be treated with respect.  We want to be your friends.  We want to be loved by our families.

130510 Blue

Changing subjects to a lighter mood, today is the one year birthday of my blog.  Thank you for stopping by to see what I have posted.  Let’s celebrate with sugar cookies :)

130510 Brown 130510 Green 130510 Mix 130510 Pink

 

 

Still Water – Thoughts on the Gay Mormon Stories Interview of Bryan Hendrickson & Adam Allred

121113 Lake Land

I went with Gregory last fall when he prepared his lake house for winter.  We talked a lot those first days of dating, with some of our conversations being painful.  He had said a few times that I was like still water.  I think I asked him during this drive to explain what he meant.

He replied that still water ran deep.  My thoughts were deep.  I had to analyze situations to the most minute detail.  I took each piece of information and studied it from all angles until I figured out how it fit in the puzzle of my life.  When something was not resolved I put it on the shelf in my mind till I had information that led to resolution.

I asked if he had ever known anyone who thought the way that I thought, meaning the method.  He said, “No.”  I already knew that he did not know anyone whose story was similar to mine.

I told him today that I think I finally found someone else who thinks like I think and whose story shares some commonality with me.  In fact, I found two people.

The most recent Gay Mormon Stories interview is with Bryan Hendrickson and Adam Allred, The two are friends – not romantic partners.  They were interviewed together because they share similar paths with different outcomes and are still dear friends.  The interview is presented in three podcasts that last three and one-half hours.

We had a lot of childhood and youth similarities.  We were academically oriented rather than interested in sports, devoted to the church, had pioneer heritage, and had loving families.  They were the oldest children in their families while I was the youngest child.  Bryan moved around more and lived in Japan.  They went to high school in a Mormon town in Arizona.  I grew up in Bountiful, Utah with a short stay in Ohio.  I experienced some bullying in junior high, like Adam.

Some of the most significant similarities to my story were recognizing early that something was different from most boys but being clueless about being attracted to guys, lack of experimentation, and being older than most men when they finally realized they were gay.  They did a lot of reading on the subject, like me, though my study came only in the past year once I finally came out.

I recall the euphoria at finally feeling romantic love and of being with someone with whom I felt an emotional attraction.  I also remember the deep, devastating sadness when the first romance ended.  That was one of my biggest reasons for staying in the closet so long and not dating.

Both people have been very invested in LGBTQ outreach.  That is a newer emphasis for me, working with the Triad Pride Mens’ Chorus.  When I realized I was gay I threw myself into pet rescue, though that was a sub-conscious decision.  I was extremely busy with my career, like they were busy with graduate and medical school.

I met smart, sensitive, high quality gay people earlier than Bryan or Adam, during my Freshman year at the University of Utah.  Bryan and Adam graduated from BYU before there were out LGBTQ students.  One later difference was the number of supportive organizations and people they found as young adults compared to the dearth of resources and people I found as an older person.

Unlike Bryan and Adam, I was not active in the Mormon church when my gay realization came.  They dedicated a significant amount of time and energy reconciling their gay and Mormon identities with varying outcomes.  I am at peace with my decision to resign from the church.  I am so happy to be in a committed relationship.  Adam backed off from dating and is active in the church.  Bryan decided later to date.  I think he feels a real loss in wanting more from the church than it has been able to give him in recent years.  (I was quite tired when I listened to the last interview and may have misunderstood that point.)

My most significant differences from Bryan and Adam were my marriage and being a father.  I was indoctrinated to the point of almost being asexual when I married.  I thought my lack of romance was due to my hyper-vigilance at living the church’s law of chastity.  I am glad our son realized he was gay and came out early in college instead of trying to go on a mission to make the gay go away.

There are more thoughts from these interviews that tie in with other recent events.  I will put those in a future post.  I am so appreciative to Bryan and Adam for sharing their stories and to Daniel Parkinson for leading the interview.  It is nice to find some stories that have more overlap with my experiences than what I usually hear or read.

121113 Lake Port

Regrets?

130507 1 trees in corner

Certain times and places are more conducive for thinking.  At home it is when I sit out back and look over to this corner of my yard.  It is my favorite focal point.  Yesterday (before the BAD storm hit) was my first chance recently to sit outside, look over at the corner, and think.

I thought of a question that was recently posed to some older people on Facebook:  Did they have any regrets?  My thoughts wandered to another question I was asked a few weeks ago:  Did I regret not coming out earlier?

A risk in answering either question is that life’s experiences get added to the evaluation.  If I could be twenty or twenty-five but have the knowledge from experiences in the rest of my life I might be tempted to wish I could re-live my life.  As it stands, I do not regret the decisions I made at twenty, twenty-five, thirty, thirty-five, and forty based on what I knew at those ages.  I also do not regret the decision around age forty-five to divorce.

I thought about the timing of my coming out.  Ten years ago I felt I made the right decision to stay in the closet.  I wondered if that decision was wrong considering how many people who knew me figured out I was gay before I came out.  I thought about the turmoil I felt the past year.  I decided that while I do not want re-live those months that I handled coming out fairly well.

One of the main reasons I do not regret when I came out is that I met Gregory.  I doubt we would have met sooner if I had come out earlier.  It is six months later and we are still in love :)

I thought about other parts of my life.  I wished some things were different, especially that I did not have these health problems, but I realized my situation is not as bad compared to what other people have in their lives.

After staring at the trees on this side of my yard I looked to the other side.  This is what I saw.

130507 2 trees clouds sky

It, too, was a nice view.  I don’t have regrets.

 

Pride Parades 2013

A year ago I worked on the logistics and publicity for Mormon contingents marching in gay pride parades in favor of civil marriage equality.  Our group was Mormons for Marriage Equality.  It was led by two church members in the Pacific Northwest who came up with the idea of Mormons marching for civil marriage equality in Pride Parades.  We were joined by Affirmation in organizing at the local level in almost twenty cities.

A different group led the Salt Lake Pride parade.  That group asked Mormons for Marriage Equality to not march as a separate contingent.  Mormons for Marriage Equality promoted and encouraged its supporters in Salt Lake to march with the other group.

DC CapitolA week later Mormons for Marriage Equality marched in the Washington, D.C. Pride Parade.  We thought there would be one to two dozen marchers.  Instead, over seventy people –  a mix of active, church-attending straight and gay Mormons, former and excommunicated gay Mormons, and family members and friends – marched to the shock and cheers of the crowd.  The D.C. Pride Parade became a spiritual experience.

This CNN iReport titled A Mormon Homecoming at the DC Pride Parade from Spencer Clark confirmed for me that what we were doing had significance:

“. . . the most touching moment for me was when one guy in a dark blue shirt busted through several rows of spectators and ran into the middle of our contingent, giving me and a few others HUGE hugs. With tears in his eyes cried out, “Oh my gosh, the Mormons are here!… I’m Mormon! I can’t believe you’re here. THANK YOU, SO MUCH” He just kept repeating, “I can’t believe it… thank you!” as he cried softly on my shoulder.”

Some people assumed that Mormons were marching to gain support for Mitt Romney’s presidential campaign.  They said that the Mormons would not be back in 2013.

Those people were wrong.  It is 2013 and Mormons are marching again in Pride Parades.

Mormon Pride lists the groups supporting contingents and where they are marching.  The first group already marched in Phoenix on April 6.  Salt Lake is next on June 3.  Washington DC follows on June 8.

Some things changed from last year.  The scope of Mormons for Marriage Equality was expanded to include support of non-discrimination legislation.  Their name was changed to Mormons for Equality.  Spencer Clark, who reported on the above DC homecoming, became the Executive Director of the group.  Mormons for Equality will march in Salt Lake to show that gay people deserve love – AND equality.

I pulled back from active participation to focus on my recuperation.  I need to turn down the invitation to march on in DC on June 8.  But one person I worked with, John, an unmarried man who organized last year’s DC contingent, will march again.  John is from Maryland, where marriage equality passed a few months later.  He and his partner of over twenty years were recently married.  That, I think, is the most meaningful change since 2012.

 

Random Stuff about Aging and Mormons with a Gay Twist

Age at Coming Out

In the past two days I read about two gay men who came out in their 60s.  I do not know either of them and doubt that we will ever meet.  Still, it was interesting (and nice) to know about people who were older than me when they came out.

One story was in QNotes, the Carolinas LGBTQ newspaper.  The person turned to a support group in Charlotte for older gay and bisexual men.  I do not recall finding that group last year when I was searching for support groups.  I started out looking in the Triad area, but expanded my search to Charlotte and Raleigh.

130502 CharlotteQNotes has a separate link to resources for older LGBTQ people.  I included it if any of my readers live in NC and are older, like me.  Naturally the resources are in the Charlotte and Raleigh areas.  That leaves around ninety-five counties (like mine) that are at least an hour away from any gay senior support resources.

Health care and housing are two of the biggest concerns for gay seniors.  That makes sense.  Those are some of the biggest concerns for straight people.  Once again, perhaps gay and straight people are more alike than different.

417

The health care concerns hit home due to my recent surgery.  Many gay people, like me, do not live close to their families.  My son came to help the first two weeks around the surgery.  I am fortunate to have friends who have helped and continue to help during my recuperation..

Gay Mormons in North Carolina

Randall Thacker, the President of the gay Mormon support group Affirmation, will be in North Carolina tomorrow night.  He contacted the people he knew to see if we would like to meet for dinner.  One of the people in Raleigh has pulled together arrangements and dinner reservations.

I plan to go as long as my back will hold out.  The group was kind enough to schedule it west of Raleigh so I will have a shorter drive.  Gregory hopes to attend.  He has been sick.  I would love to be there with him, but I hope he will not make the trip unless he feels a lot better.  His commute would be even longer since he lives west of me.

So why am I interested in meeting this group?  There is a shared heritage, whether the people were born into the Mormon church or joined later in life and whether they grew up in Utah or elsewhere.

I felt very alone last year.  I had no support group.  I got some greatly appreciated help online from Randall and others within Affirmation and Mormons for Equality.  It is nice to know there are allies and other gay Mormons in the state.   I hope people in the future who live here and have some gay and Mormon intersection in their lives know they have someone to talk to in North Carolina.

 

Coming Out – Jason Collins and Me

“I’m a 34-year-old NBA center. I’m black. And I’m gay.”

Obviously that is not me talking.  It is NBA center Jason Collins in this first-person Sports Illustrated story titled Why NBA Center Jason Collins is Coming Out Now.  Here are a few excerpts in italics from the article interspersed with some of my thoughts:

“I didn’t set out to be the first openly gay athlete playing in a major American  team sport. But since I am, I’m happy to start the conversation. I wish I wasn’t  the kid in the classroom raising his hand and saying, “I’m different.” If I had  my way, someone else would have already done this. Nobody has, which is why I’m  raising my hand.”

I live in a “don’t ask, don’t tell” community.  I grew up in a “don’t ask, don’t tell” community, too.  I would rather live in a world where people do not have to come out as gay just like they currently do not have to come out as straight, but that does not describe today’s environment.  One of my favorite bloggers, Kiley, has the following quote that explains what coming out means:

“Coming out of the closet is really about becoming yourself and being confident and secure in who you are.  Coming out is about dropping facades.”

In my case, coming out means I no longer feel like I have to apologize for who I am.

“The first relative I came out to was my aunt Teri, a superior court judge in San  Francisco. Her reaction surprised me. “I’ve known you were gay for years,” she  said. From that moment on I was comfortable in my own skin. In her presence I  ignored my censor button for the first time. She gave me support. The relief I  felt was a sweet release. Imagine you’re in the oven, baking. Some of us know  and accept our sexuality right away and some need more time to cook. I should  know — I baked for 33 years.”

I “baked” longer than most people.  To date, I have not met anyone who was older than me when they finally realized they were gay.  I only know one person who was older than me when he came out to his family.

Collins twin brother had no idea that Jason was gay.  His family’s reaction was similar to mine, with some knowing for a long time that I am gay while others were shocked.

There is a sense of relief in coming out.  It creates some complications, but I think the positives outweigh the negatives.

“I’m from a close-knit family. My parents instilled Christian values in me. They  taught Sunday school, and I enjoyed lending a hand. I take the teachings of  Jesus seriously, particularly the ones that touch on tolerance and  understanding. On family trips, my parents made a point to expose us to new  things, religious and cultural. In Utah, we visited the Mormon Salt Lake Temple.  In Atlanta, the house of Martin Luther King Jr. That early exposure to otherness  made me the guy who accepts everyone unconditionally.”

The most significant experience of my Mormon childhood was moving to Ohio when I was five.  It was the first time I was a religious minority.  I learned what it was like to be different.  I think that experience, combined with my father’s exposure to lots of people from different backgrounds, my mother’s kind heart, plus my mission experiences of living in heavily unionized Michigan followed by thirteen months in Brazil, taught me to love unconditionally.

“I’m learning to embrace the puzzle that is me. After I was traded by the Celtics  to Washington in February, I took a detour to the Dr. King memorial. I was  inspired and humbled. I celebrate being an African-American and the hardships of  the past that still resonate today. But I don’t let my race define me any more  than I want my sexual orientation to. I don’t want to be labeled, and I can’t  let someone else’s label define me.”

I am still learning who I am.  My post the other day about my teenage lack of dating experience touched on that a bit.  The early readers of my blog saw a lot of entries about my learning process.

My fundamental personality traits have not changed.  I have more of an understanding on how my background and experiences, especially in the Mormon church, have both helped and harmed me.  Understanding what was damaging is helping me as I move forward.  I hope I am always moving forward because there is still a lot of self-doubt to overcome.

“The strain of hiding my sexuality became almost unbearable in March, when the  U.S. Supreme Court heard arguments for and against same-sex marriage. Less than  three miles from my apartment, nine jurists argued about my happiness  and my future. Here was my chance to be heard, and I couldn’t say a  thing. I didn’t want to answer questions and draw attention to myself. Not while  I was still playing.”

I felt the same way a year ago, except it was about  North Carolina’s Amendment One.  What really hit me in the gut was a Facebook post from a straight former co-worker that explained why she voted against the amendment.  I wished I could have made a similar statement last spring.

I made my statement last month in the post titled I Wore Red Today.  I did not expect everyone to agree and know the majority of my family and friends disagreed with me, but I think that I made my statement with courtesy.  I did not expect much, but learned that it was picked up with positive response in three other blog reviews.  That made me happy.

“Openness may not completely disarm prejudice, but it’s a good place to start. It  all comes down to education. I’ll sit down with any player who’s uneasy about my  coming out. Being gay is not a choice. This is the tough road and at times the  lonely road.”

I hope my blog is doing some educating.  A few people told me I was the first gay person who they had worked with or been around.  One said that she had to re-think what she thought she knew about gay people because what her church taught did not match what she knew about me.

I did not plan to write a new blog post this evening.  I felt okay – just tired from what for me was a busy morning.  These medications, combined with month of back pain, have completely thrown off my sleep routine.  I needed to get up earlier today, though, for a re-scheduled dentist appointment.

I did this shout out to my dentists, their staff, and extended family a few weeks ago.  I made a generic reference to the families’ kindness.  Here is an incident that is more specific.

I felt a lot of support and acceptance last May and June when I first came out.  That support wavered in the following months.  It hit a very low point in September and October when some people made it clear that we no longer had the same relationship.  Against that backdrop I left home for a day trip along the Blue Ridge Parkway.

2012 BRP 3The drive was mostly a scenic photography bust until I saw a small section of the creek in the Julian Price Park.  I wrote about it in this post.  Once I found this beautiful spot I decided it was time to grab a quick bite to eat and return home before it got too late.

I had almost finished eating at a restaurant in Boone, the home of Appalachian State University, when I saw the uncle and cousin of my dentist being seated a few booths away from me.  They are some of my favorite people, but I was almost afraid to greet them after seeing and feeling so many people pull away during the previous weeks.

They did not see me.  It would have been easy to pay and leave without them seeing me.  I got up to return home, debated with myself for a few seconds, and decided to stop at their booth on my way out of the restaurant.

They were happy to see me and greeted me just like they have always greeted me in the twenty plus years since I moved to central North Carolina.  I actually cried when I got out to my car.  It was the first I felt accepted by some long-time friends at a time when most of what I experienced was silent, slow rejection.

A few days later I stopped by the office of the wife and mom of my friends and told her how much that three-minute chat in the restaurant meant to me.  I choked up again as I thanked her and asked her to share my appreciation to her husband and son.

“I’ve been asked how other players will respond to my announcement. The simple  answer is, I have no idea. I’m a pragmatist. I hope for the best, but plan for  the worst.”

The immediate reaction to Jason Collins coming out is positive.  I think he is wise enough to know that the first acceptance will most likely wane.  When that happens I hope he will have people, like my former co-worker who wrote the Amendment One post and my dentists and their families, who will stand with him.

Getting to Know You – LGBTQ Dating and Family Acceptance Project Resources

The High Point Furniture Market attracts more people than there are available hotel rooms.  There is a long-standing tradition for market visitors to stay in people’s homes.  One of Gregory’s friends from the west coast stays at his home during each market.  They share blunt humor.

I met her over dinner early in the market.  She said watching Gregory and me was enough to make her diabetic.  I thought that was funny.  Public displays of affection by same-sex couples are not welcomed in this part of North Carolina.  We do not hug, hold hands, or get affectionate in public but our smiles and interactions made it clear to her that Gregory and I are happy together. That made me feel good.

We have dated over five months and are still happy to see each other.  We do not take our relationship for granted.  Meeting and dating are not easy for middle-aged gay people in semi-rural central North Carolina.

I have straight friends who have done middle-aged or senior dating due to death or divorces.  Most say it is more enjoyable that dating was when they were teens or young adults.  They are more comfortable being themselves as adults than they were as teens.

Many LGBTQ people, myself included, do not have much teen dating experience to compare with our adult dating experience.  I think very few gay teens have much experience with dating even today. Most of us miss out on the early part of the dating process.  I think that makes it more difficult for gay people to find and have healthy relationships.

If you are a parent of a gay teen and are trying to decide if you will let your child date, here are some excerpts from Family Re-Union written by Hollie Hancock for No More Strangers: LGBT Mormon Forum.  The author is a therapist who works with LGBTQ clients and their families.

“Second, if your LGBTQ loved one is a minor and still living at home, reiterate and/or clearly define the boundaries, guidelines, and expectations for all members of your household.  “House Rules” rule, if you will.  If curfew is midnight in your home, everyone residing in that home abides by this rule. . .”

“If there is a specific rule in your home about when group or solo dating begins, this rule applies to all of your children.  This becomes difficult as there are not many opportunities for LGBTQ youth to mix, mingle, socialize, or date other LGBTQ youth in safe settings.  However, keep your eyes open, some communities have organizations that create events for LGBTQ teens to mix and mingle.  Gay Prom for example, is an excellent event that is fun and safe place for LGBTQ teens to socialize.  Arguably, more of these types of events need to be available on a consistent basis.  However, every event held or created for LGBTQ teens is one step closer to preventing this young population from risky behaviors and unsafe circumstances.”

This video is about a young man who came out to his family earlier than many people come out.  His family now supports him dating the same way they support his straight brother’s dating.

The dating discussion starts around the 11:40 mark of the video, but I hope you will watch the entire video.  It talks about cultural issues that made it hard to come out. It talks about his bad experiences dealing with depression as a closeted gay teen. It talks about research his parents did to educate themselves and what they are doing to help their son and other LGBTQ people.

The video is part of the Family Acceptance Project.  This description is from their home page:

“The Family Acceptance Project™ is the only  community research, intervention, education and policy initiative that works to decrease major health and related risks for lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) youth, such as suicide, substance abuse, HIV and homelessness – in the context of their families. We use a research-based, culturally grounded approach to help ethnically, socially and religiously diverse families decrease rejection and increase support for their LGBT children.”

Here is the link to the Family Acceptance Project booklets that have information for families of LGBTQ teens.  One booklet is written specifically for Mormon families.

There are more LGBTQ resources today with scientific support than there was when Gregory or I were teens.  Unfortunately, many families and faith leaders still use assumptions they learned twenty to forty years ago.  Gay people are at unnecessary risk due to those outdated ideas. “Getting to know you” is not limited just to dating. It means learning how to have a place in the family for GLBTQ family members.

The Boy Scouts of America and Me – Revisited

Scout OathI loved the Cub Scout program.  I did not like the Boy Scout program.  Most of the young men in my troop did not care for scouting, either.  On our last camp out, we sold fertilizer as a fund-raiser and took the cash and booked two nights at the then new Bloomington Resort outside of St. George, Utah.

My son was interested in Cub Scouts and Boy Scouts.  I assisted as a volunteer on Cub Scout activities and pack meetings.  I was a member of the Scout Committee and continued as a Merit Badge Counselor for a while after his scouting career ended.  My gay awakening did not come until counseling that happened after my divorce.  I had ended my relationship with the Boy Scouts and was not aware of their policy against gays.

Here are a few things my son’s Cub Scout and Boy Scout programs would have missed out on if I had been excluded for being gay:

  1. A parent volunteer to aid the Cub Master each week – it was a large pack with around 30 boys;
  2. A parent volunteer who could give some extra attention to a topic when one or two boys needed more guidance on learning or doing whatever was being demonstrated;
  3. A committee member who understood documentation and paperwork – more on that later;
  4. A merit badge counselor who was qualified and evaluated the performance of scouts who asked to pass the Citizenship in the Community, Citizenship in the Nation, Citizenship in the World, Genealogy, Pets, and Scholarship merit badges – more on that later;
  5. A person who knew how to make adjustments in the process to allow scouts with developmental challenges understand and pass the requited Citizenship merit badges;  (These changes were authorized by people up the line to make sure that we followed the BSA’s rules.)
  6. A person who filled in some of the financial gaps when funds were short;
  7. A person who paid the camp fees for another scout when his parents were unable or unwilling to pay the fees – more on that later, too.

We lived in a small community in a different county from our ward while my son was in Cub Scouts.  He belonged to a pack sponsored by another church. Scouting positions in most troops were filled by people who enjoyed scouting.  We moved to the county where our ward was located when my son became a Scout, so he belonged to our Mormon ward’s troop.  Positions were church callings, and they were the last callings that some of our scouting adults wanted.

Our troop had a good record for scouts becoming Eagles (if that was their goal) up until three years before I was asked to be on the Scout Committee.  None of the adults in the program wanted to be bothered with documentation for three years.  Merit badges were earned, but no one tracked the scouts’ progress towards the various scouting ranks.

When I became a member of the committee I received a box filled with the troop copies of the merit badges that had been awarded.  I decided to see who had earned what and to see if anyone had earned any ranks that had not been awarded.  It took a month to work my way through the stacks of merit badge cards.  We discovered a few ranks that had been earned but not awarded since no one submitted any documentation for three years.

I made one discovery that saddened me.  One month before a young man turned eighteen, I determined he had earned every one of the merit badges for his Eagle.  He did not have a service project, though.  The young man’s family went through a lot of turmoil the previous few years.  Technically, the scout and his parents should have been aware of his progress.  They were not, though.  I asked the mother and scout if they were interested in trying to pull together an Eagle project in that last month.  It was not worth it to him at the time, but it would have been a year or two earlier.

That was the last time that a scout and his family were not aware of his progress while I was on the committee.  They received quarterly updates, and I met with the scouts and parents who had the goal of earning the Eagle.  It has been a while so my memory may be off, but I believe we awarded three eagles in our relatively small troop during my tenure on the committee.

We had lots of merit badge counselors for the “fun” badges – camping, swimming, etc.  We had few for the more academic badges.  At the time, I was the only person in our troop who was qualified and willing to be a counselor for the badges in item #4 of the above list.  I was also the only person who was willing to serve as the Scholarship merit badge counselor for scouts from other troops in my county and an adjoining county.  Five more scouts from other troops earned their Eagles because I agreed to meet with them and their parents after hours at my employer so they could pass and earn their Scholarship merit badges.

My last point is about the scout camp fee.  One scout came from a broken home in which the parents could not put aside their animosity towards each other.  For some reason both parents refused to pay the fee for camp.  Their son wanted to attend but neither parent would back down.  When I learned the scout could not attend due to lack of payment, I wrote a check.

The parents of that scout were both qualified and had served in scouting positions.  The father was an Eagle scout himself.  There really was no good reason for their son to not attend camp, other than the parents could not work together.

I am glad that I served in scouting before I realized I was gay.  My contributions would have been the same, however.  Some boys earned their desired ranks and attended camp because of the help of a gay guy.  Not once was I tempted to do anything wrong.  The scouting program is missing out on a lot of good scouts and good leaders due to the exclusionary policy of the Boy Scouts of America towards gay scouts and gay scout leaders.

Scout EqualityI wrote the above post last summer.  I republished it because the BSA has proposed a policy change that will let gay Boy Scouts to be out and be in the Scouting program.  I am grateful for that proposed change.  Too many young men have been hurt by the current ban. 

The proposal still prohibits out gay scout leaders.  That affects some of my friends.  I believe the Scouting program will lose out if those LGBTQ parents are not welcomed as potential Scouting leaders in their sons packs and troops.  It also sends the wrong message to gay Scouts who are active in their troops and then age out at eighteen.  They will not be able to help as leaders, committee members, or merit badge counselors.

Another Update:  I am adding a link to Ally Patches to this post.  If you know a gay Boy Scout I hope you will support him.  I have read a number of stories from people who were not out but were bullied by other Scouts who guessed they were gay.

Two Hospitals, Two Families, Two Outcomes

The accident that caused a disc to rupture in my back happened shortly after my guy and I started dating.  My primary care doctor referred me to a neurologist who belonged to a larger group of doctors with expertise in the potential treatments for my problem.  That medical group sent me a Patient Information Form to complete before my first visit.

One section of the form asked me to list the people who could make medical decisions for me, the people who the practice could discuss my case and potential treatments with, and who could be present during examinations.  My legal situation is simple.  I have one son.  He gets to make the decisions.  There is one complication.  He lives on the other side of the country.

My son and my guy had not met when I was referred to the specialists.  I wanted my son to have someone he could talk with if he felt that was necessary if I could not make a medical decision.  My brother, who lives almost all the way across the US, agreed to be listed on the form.

Once my son and my guy met it was obvious that they got along well.  I could tell that both were also interested in my best will.  My guy lives less than an hour from where I live.  I told the receptionist during one doctor’s visit that I wanted to add my guy to the authorization form.  She said my verbal request was all they needed.  I am so thankful he was present, especially during the latter visits before the surgery when I was in so much pain and on so many medications.

My son was quite upset that I needed surgery.  He called his mom and asked if she would mind being with him and my guy at the hospital.  She called me and offered to come if I was okay and if my guy was okay with her being there.  My guy said he had no problem being there with my son and my former wife.  During the hospital pre-admission and confirmed that I wanted my son to have authority to make medical decisions, if needed.  I also said that I wanted my guy and my former wife to be able to consult with him and hear options if that was needed.

I contrast that with the case last week of the hospital in Missouri that had a gay partner arrested when there was a dispute between the partner and a brother of hospitalized man over who could make medical decisions.  The couple have a legally recognized civil union which grants them power of attorney to make medical decisions for each other.  The hospital had written record of that agreement.  The hospitalized man also stated that he wanted his partner present.  The hospitalized man’s siblings do not approve of his gay relationship.  He has specifically excluded them from his medical care.

This is one of several versions of the incident that have been reported.  Here is a summary of an interview with the daughter of the man who was arrested,, who saw the incident.  Here is a post that describes how later statements from the hospital about the incident differ from the hospital’s original statement.  This story from a former employee of the hospital says, “It makes news because of the f*gs.”.   This story includes quotes from both the man arrested and the brother of the patient..  The brother acknowledges that he knew he did not have authority to make medical decisions yet he tried to over-rule the partner who he knew had written legal authority.

This case illustrates why civil unions – “skim milk marriages” as described by Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg during last month’s Supreme Court oral arguments about same sex marriage – are not a satisfactory solution.  This also shows what happens when people do not respect each other.

My guy is simply my guy.  We have no legal documents that recognize any relationship.  We do not even have a term that either one of us likes to describe our relationship.  We usually introduce each other as “friends.”  The law does not need patients to have a blood or legal relationship to the people who they authorize to make medical decisions.

I am thankful that my family recognizes that my guy is special to me and more than just a “friend.” I appreciate that the hospital, like the medical practice, honored all of my requests.  I am glad that nothing happened that would have required my son to make any medical decisions.  I am also thankful that my son, my guy, and my former wife were there to support me and to support each other.